Eliminating the Consequences of Maternal Depression
Understanding the Impact and Strategies for Prevention and Treatment
Elaine DeaKyne was excited about her first pregnancy and, physically, she sailed through it without complications. Looking back, she recalls feeling anxiety during her third trimester, but she didn’t bring it up with her doctors because, as she says, “I didn’t know it was something I should talk about.” Her anxiety heightened after her daughter was born, but DeaKyne had no way of knowing that what she was experiencing was a symptom of maternal depression and could be identified and treated by professionals. No one offered her a mental health screening during her pregnancy or at her six-week follow-up check-up. No one discussed the risk and prevalence of maternal depression with her or empowered her to seek help.
DeaKyne was left alone with what became increasingly frightening thoughts and anxiety.
“When my daughter was six weeks old, I started to have these intrusive thoughts,” says DeaKyne. “There was one thought where I was walking my daughter in her stroller and just pushed her out into the street. Because of that thought, I stopped taking her out in strollers. Another time, I thought about driving over a bridge, getting out of the car, and jumping off. So, I started avoiding driving over bridges. I was so afraid of all these thoughts happening, so I just stayed home and isolated myself in this depressed state.”
DeaKyne’s experience is far from rare. Perinatal depression affects up to one in seven women in the United States. That translates to more than 180,000 mothers annually who suffer from an illness that affects their health and, as a result, the health of their children; an illness that is too often stigmatized and suffered through in silence.
Frightened by her intrusive thoughts, DeaKyne made an appointment with her obstetrician, and was immediately screened by a nurse when she arrived. At the last question of the screening, which asked if she thought she would ever hurt herself or her child, DeaKyne paused.
“I felt like the answer was, ‘I don’t know,’ but I wasn’t sure what to say,” DeaKyne. “The nurse was uncomfortable, and then she looked at me and said, ‘no, no you would never think or do that.’ She answered the question for me. In that moment, I realized I was going to leave this appointment without getting help, and I knew I really, really needed help. I just felt ashamed and afraid to say anything.”
Thankfully, DeaKyne did receive help. Her doctor also went through the screening with her and realized DeaKyne was struggling to answer that last question. Recognizing that something more serious was happening, her doctor connected DeaKyne with a therapist and she was immediately started on medication for depression and anxiety. It wasn’t the end of DeaKyne’s journey, but it was the first time someone recognized she was in need and stepped in and helped her. Now, six years since the birth of her first daughter, she is mom to two healthy daughters and serves as the Executive Director for Postpartum Support Charleston, a peer-support organization that helped her during her recovery.
DeaKyne’s story illustrates the critical need to do more to support the thousands of mothers and families affected by maternal depression. NICHQ’s recent webinar, Maternal Depression: Everyone Can Play a Role to Help Families Thrive, was dedicated to helping fill that need. During the webinar, DeaKyne shared her story alongside three other experts from the Brookings Institution, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and the Medical University of South Carolina. Together, their insights demonstrate maternal depression’s significant impact on mothers and families, and offer strategies health professionals can take to ensure that more mothers are screened and referred to support and resources.
Below, we share three high-level takeaways.
Lesson one: Maternal depression negatively impacts early childhood development and ultimately hinders future economic mobility
Maternal depression adversely affects the health of mothers, and in turn, the health of their children. This alone is significant, but it has additional concerning implications when considered within the context of economic mobility and cycles of poverty, explains Richard V. Reeves, PhD, Director of the Future of Middle Class Initiative and Co-Director of the Center on Children and Families at the Brookings Institution.
In what Reeves calls the “depression immobility cycle,” maternal depression is one piece within a larger cycle that feeds intergenerational economic inequalities. In sum: Poverty increases the risk of mental health problems, including maternal depression. In response, mothers experiencing maternal depression may have difficulty engaging in attachment forming behaviors and interactions. For example, because they feel disengaged, they may struggle to participate in “serve and return” interactions, where caregivers provide meaningful, appropriate responses to children’s gestures or sounds. These interactions shape brain architecture and without them, children’s developmental health suffers. Decades of early childhood science tells us that slower early childhood development affects children’s ability to succeed at school and develop meaningful relationships; simply put, a slower start results in worse outcomes. And consequently, children grow into adults who may struggle to find and maintain good employment, and eventually end up in poverty, facing the same risks of depression as their parents.
This cycle comes from a recent paper co-authored by Reeves, which examines the evidence for each stage of the cycle in detail. Ultimately, it points to the essential need to break this cycle at each and every stage and, says Reeves, “put mental health, especially maternal depression, at the center of the mobility debate.”
Lesson two: Leveraging preventive interventions for perinatal depression can help break the cycle
Early in 2019, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force released a new recommendation related to maternal depression: all pregnant and postpartum individuals at an increased risk for developing perinatal depression should be referred to counseling interventions. This recommendation reflects convincing evidence that effective counseling interventions can help prevent depression before it even develops, says Vice-Chairperson Karina Davidson, PhD, MASc.
The Task Force found that when women engaged in effective counseling—specifically, either cognitive behavioral therapy or interpersonal therapy—there was a 39-percent reduction in the likelihood of depression. Consider DeaKyne’s story: if she had received preventive counseling, she would have had to the tools to address her symptoms more immediately, or may never have experienced depression at all. Consider what that means for the nearly 200,000 mothers experiencing depression every year, and the thousands of mothers who never receive support and treatment.
While there is no accurate screening tool for assessing whether a person is at risk for depression, the Task Force did identify several factors that health professionals can look for. Specifically, says Davidson, health professionals should refer women to counseling if they have one or more of the following risk factors: a history of depression; current depressive symptoms (that do not reach a diagnostic threshold); socioeconomic risk factors such as low income or adolescent or single parenthood; recent intimate partner violence; and mental health-related factors, such as elevated anxiety symptoms. While there are no data on timing of referral, most of the interventions that were beneficial were initiated during the second trimester of pregnancy.
Along with preventive interventions, Davidson notes that the task force recommends screening all pregnant and postpartum women for maternal depression, and screening women of child-bearing age for intimate partner violence, which, if positive, signals the need for preventive interventions.
Lesson three: Strategies to increase access to treatment
Only 30 to 50 percent of women with mental illness during pregnancy and postpartum are diagnosed in a clinical setting, says Constance Guille, MD, Associate Professor and Director of the Women’s Reproductive Behavioral Health Program at the Medical University of South Carolina. Of that number, fewer than 20 percent are referred to treatment and fewer than five percent achieve remission from the disease.
Leveraging recommended screening tools for maternal depression, such as the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), can help identify more mothers suffering from depression, says Guille, but we also need to put significant effort into addressing the barriers to treatment—namely a lack of access and stigma. Below, Guille offers four strategies she’s leveraged successfully in her own work:
Ensuring Flexible Evaluation as Project Needs Change
Have you ever had to update your program implementation plan part way through? We’re sharing four strategies on creating flexible evaluation processes for greater program success.
Innovative Strategies for Promoting Developmental Health in Rural Alaska
In Kodiak Alaska's remote island community, it can be difficult for families to connect with public health and community resources, especially during the early years of life when children are developing rapidly. Learn how they're leveraging innovative strategies to promote developmental health in this article.
Seven Strategies for Conducting Successful Services Virtually
Across the country, health and social service providers have had to find news way to support children and families in the face of COVID-19. Home visiting services, pediatric well-child visits, prenatal care and mental health appointments have largely had to transition from in-person appointments to visits virtually—either via phone or video. By learning how to conduct a successful virtual visit, health and social service providers can help ensure children and families receive the support they need during and after this pandemic.
In the Face of COVID-19, Baltimore Healthy Start Builds Resiliency
The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted daily life across the country, with schools and childcare closed, routine medical care delayed, public transportation limited, and millions of jobs lost. These disruptions have disproportionately affected vulnerable low-income communities where families already face significant threats to their health and well-being, including housing and food insecurity and less access to medical care. In response, Baltimore Healthy Start, Inc. has launched a multi-pronged approach to support the families they serve.
Strengthening Early Childhood Systems: Lessons from the Pandemic and a Call to Action
For years, experts have called for a comprehensive system that links young children and families to needed health and social services at the community, state, and federal level. The coronavirus pandemic has revealed that the need for that system is more urgent than ever.